Delaware DUI Court Process: From Arraignment to Disposition
It Starts in the Justice of the Peace Court
A first-offense misdemeanor DUI case in Delaware begins in the Justice of the Peace (JP) Court. The criminal summons you received at arrest lists your initial court date and location. At that appearance, a JP Court magistrate reads the charges and explains the potential penalties.
Here is what catches most people off guard: the JP Court is a court of limited jurisdiction. In most situations, there is no prosecutor or public defender at this level; public defenders are available in only a very limited number of JP Court cases. A public defender is available in the Court of Common Pleas if you qualify.
The Jurisdictional Decision
At your initial JP Court appearance, you face a choice that shapes the rest of your case:
Stay in JP Court: JP Court can accept a guilty plea or a First Offense Election, but it does not have jurisdiction to try a DUI. A not-guilty DUI case goes to the Court of Common Pleas for trial.
Transfer to the Court of Common Pleas: The CCP hears misdemeanor motor-vehicle offenses and provides a jury trial. Prosecutors and public defenders for qualifying defendants are available there. The transfer is a one-way door — once a case moves to the CCP, it cannot return to JP Court.
At arraignment, defendants may choose to have an eligible case handled in JP Court or transfer it to CCP. A DUI defendant does not need to transfer to CCP to apply for the First Offense Election; JP Court can enter the conditional adjudication for FOE.
What Happens at the Court of Common Pleas
If your case transfers to — or begins at — the CCP, the process becomes more formal:
- Arraignment: The charges are read again, you enter a plea, and the court sets a schedule
- FOE application: If you qualify, you can apply for the First Offense Election at this stage — the court defers proceedings without a judgment of guilt
- Pre-trial motions: Your attorney (private or public defender) can file motions to suppress evidence, challenge the traffic stop, or contest the chemical test
- Trial or disposition: The case either resolves through a plea, the FOE program, or proceeds to trial
For defendants who entered the FOE, the court defers the case. You complete the program requirements — treatment, interlock, compliance — and the case resolves without a DUI conviction on your record.
Free Download
Get the Delaware — DUI First 30 Days Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Aggravated Cases Go to Superior Court
A DUI incident that causes serious physical injury or death can also lead to separate felony vehicular assault or vehicular homicide charges. If a DUI-related case is charged as a felony, the JP Court may conduct the initial appearance and the Court of Common Pleas may hold a preliminary hearing. If CCP finds probable cause, it binds the case over to Superior Court for further proceedings.
The Court Track Is Separate From the DMV Track
One thing that confuses nearly everyone: the criminal court case and the DMV administrative hearing are independent proceedings. A dismissal in court does not undo a DMV revocation. A DMV hearing loss does not affect your criminal defense. They run on different timelines, before different decision-makers, under different standards of proof.
The criminal track uses "beyond a reasonable doubt." In a probable-cause administrative hearing, the DMV decides whether a preponderance of the evidence shows a DUI violation; a refusal hearing determines whether you refused testing after being told the penalty. You can win one track and lose the other.
The Delaware First-Offense DUI Guide maps both tracks on a single timeline so you can see where the court dates, DMV deadlines, and treatment requirements overlap.
Get Your Free Delaware — DUI First 30 Days Checklist
Download the Delaware — DUI First 30 Days Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.