Mandatory vs Discretionary Expungement in Delaware
Mandatory Expungement: Administrative, No Judge
Mandatory expungement under 11 Del. C. § 4373 is handled entirely by the State Bureau of Identification. You never appear before a judge, and the SBI cannot deny your application if you meet the statutory criteria.
Who qualifies:
- Charges dismissed, acquitted, or entered as nolle prosequi — no waiting period
- Successfully completed Probation Before Judgment (PBJ) — no waiting period
- Single violation conviction with no other convictions — 3-year waiting period
- Single eligible misdemeanor conviction with no other convictions — 5-year waiting period
How it works: Pull your certified criminal history via IdentoGO ($72), receive the SBI's determination letter (about two weeks), then sign and return the mandatory application packet within 30 days with a $75 money order payable to the Delaware State Police. Processing takes roughly three to six months.
The Clean Slate Act also enables automatic clearance for mandatory-eligible records through monthly batch sweeps — but with a backlog exceeding one million cases, filing manually is faster when you need results on a deadline.
Discretionary Expungement: Court Petition Required
Discretionary expungement under 11 Del. C. § 4374 requires filing a formal petition in court. A judge evaluates whether keeping the record public creates "manifest injustice" — the legal standard you need to meet.
Who needs this route:
- Misdemeanors on the statutory exclusion list (domestic violence offenses, vehicular assault 2nd degree, coercion, others) — 7-year waiting period
- Standard misdemeanors that don't qualify for mandatory clearance — 3-year waiting period
- Non-violent felonies in eligible categories — 7-year waiting period from conviction or release
How it works: After pulling your SBI report and getting the determination letter (which will indicate you need the court route), you file a petition in either Family Court or Superior Court:
- Family Court — if all charges originated there. No filing fee. Use Form 281 (petition) and Form 283 (proposed order).
- Superior Court — if any charge was decided outside Family Court. $75 filing fee. Use Form CIV_EXP_02_A (petition) and CIV_EXP_04_A (proposed order).
After filing, the Attorney General's office gets 120 days to review and respond. If they object, you have 30 days to file a written reply. Most cases are decided on paper — physical hearings are rare and only happen when a judge needs additional testimony.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Mandatory | Discretionary | |
|---|---|---|
| Decided by | SBI (administrative) | Judge (court petition) |
| Legal standard | Statutory criteria — if you qualify, it's granted | "Manifest injustice" — judge has discretion |
| Court appearance | None | Rare but possible |
| Filing fee | $75 SBI fee (+ $72 fingerprinting) | $0–$75 court fee (+ $72 fingerprinting) |
| AG review period | None | 120 days |
| Typical timeline | 3–6 months | 4–6 months |
| Applies to | Non-convictions, violations, eligible misdemeanors | Excluded misdemeanors, eligible felonies |
Free Download
Get the Delaware — Expungement Eligibility Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Which One Applies to You
The SBI's determination letter is the official answer. When you pull your criminal history and the SBI reviews your records, the letter they mail will either include the mandatory application packet or tell you to petition the court.
If your case ended without a conviction (dismissed, acquitted, nolle prosequi) and you have no other convictions, you're almost certainly on the mandatory track. If you have a conviction on your record — even a single misdemeanor — the pathway depends on the offense type, the elapsed time, and whether you have any other convictions.
For a structured walkthrough of both pathways, including the document assembly checklist and post-order verification steps, our Delaware Expungement & Record Sealing Guide covers every scenario.
Get Your Free Delaware — Expungement Eligibility Checklist
Download the Delaware — Expungement Eligibility Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.