$0 Ohio — Expungement Eligibility Checklist

Best Ohio Record Sealing Guide for People With Multiple Convictions

The Short Answer

If you have multiple convictions on your Ohio record, you're not automatically disqualified from sealing — but the rules are more specific than for a single-offense case. Ohio generally allows sealing any number of eligible convictions, but limits apply to certain third-degree felony convictions. The statute has rules for counting convictions as one under those limits. The best resource for this situation is one that explains the counting rules clearly and walks through the eligibility analysis before you spend money filing a petition. The Ohio Expungement & Record Sealing Guide includes the eligibility matrix with the counting rules built into the decision tree.

Why Multiple Convictions Complicate Eligibility (But Don't Kill It)

Ohio generally allows sealing any number of eligible convictions, but limits apply to certain third-degree felony convictions. The way Ohio counts convictions for those limits is not intuitive — and it's the reason many people with multiple charges either file incorrectly or assume they're ineligible when they're not.

The conviction-count rule for third-degree felonies. Convictions connected with the same act or offenses committed at the same time count as one. Two or three convictions from the same indictment, information, or complaint, guilty plea, or official proceeding also count as one when they arise from related criminal acts within a three-month period, unless the court finds that doing so is not in the public interest.

The third-degree-felony limits. Ohio generally allows sealing any number of eligible convictions. A third-degree felony is excluded if you have more than one other felony conviction. If you have exactly two third-degree felony convictions, they are excluded when your total number of convictions exceeds those two felonies plus two misdemeanors.

These limits apply to third-degree felonies; eligible convictions otherwise have no general numerical cap.

The waiting period compounds. Each conviction has its own waiting period calculated from that case's final discharge date. If you apply to seal several convictions, check each one against its own waiting period; filing too early can result in denial for a conviction that is not yet eligible.

What to Look for in a Guide

A guide that works for single-conviction cases may not work for yours. Here's what matters when multiple convictions are involved:

A counting tool, not just a rule statement. You need something that takes your actual convictions and tells you how Ohio counts them under the third-degree-felony limits. That means applying the same-act, same-time, and related-conviction rules. The Ohio Expungement & Record Sealing Guide presents this as an eligibility matrix you work through with your own record.

Multiple-county filing guidance. If your convictions are in different counties, you file separate applications in each sentencing court. Local filing instructions and fees can differ. A guide that only covers one county's process leaves you guessing for the other.

Waiting-period calculation for multiple cases. The final discharge date for each case may be different — different sentencing dates, different probation lengths, different fine payment schedules. You need to calculate each one and identify which one controls your earliest filing date.

Hearing preparation for multi-conviction cases. When you have multiple convictions, the judge's balancing test takes a broader view of your record. The rehabilitation evidence you present needs to cover the full arc — not just "I haven't reoffended" but a documented trajectory showing what's changed since the last conviction.

Free Download

Get the Ohio — Expungement Eligibility Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Comparison of Resources for Multi-Conviction Cases

Resource Handles Same-Indictment Rule Multi-County Filing Aggregate Cap Calculation Hearing Prep
Ohio Supreme Court forms No Separate packets per county No No
Legal aid (if available) Attorney analyzes Attorney handles Attorney calculates Attorney represents
Generic self-help book Usually not Ohio-specific No No General
Ohio Expungement Guide Full counting matrix Franklin, Cuyahoga, Hamilton, Montgomery Built into eligibility tree Statutory factors + evidence checklist
Expungement attorney Yes Per-county fee Yes Full representation

Who This Is For

  • People with multiple convictions who aren't sure how the third-degree-felony limits apply
  • Anyone with multiple charges who needs to understand the third-degree-felony counting rules
  • Filers with convictions in multiple Ohio counties who need to coordinate separate petitions
  • People who were told before April 4, 2023, that they had "too many" convictions — current law generally permits any number of eligible convictions, subject to the third-degree-felony limits
  • Anyone whose background check shows multiple items and who wants to understand which ones can be sealed and in what order

Who This Is NOT For

  • People with pending charges in addition to past convictions — the pending case must resolve first
  • Anyone with a conviction excluded from sealing (other eligible convictions may still be sealable, subject to the third-degree-felony limits)
  • Filers whose convictions may exceed the third-degree-felony limits even after applying the counting rules — though this is worth verifying, because many people overcount

The Filing-Order Question

When you have multiple eligible convictions, the order you file petitions matters. Ohio courts consider each petition against your full record at the time of filing. If you have convictions in multiple counties, filing simultaneously can create complications — one court may grant your petition while another hasn't ruled yet, changing the conviction count the second court sees.

The practical approach: start with the conviction that's most clearly eligible and in the county with the fastest processing time. Once that order is granted, file the next petition. This is slower but reduces the risk of a denial based on a conviction that was about to be sealed anyway.

The guide's filing-preparation section walks through this sequencing question for multi-petition filers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the same-indictment rule apply to charges from different arrests?

Not automatically. For the third-degree-felony count, convictions connected with the same act or offenses committed at the same time count as one. Two or three convictions from the same indictment, information, or complaint, guilty plea, or official proceeding also count as one if they arise from related criminal acts committed within three months, unless the court finds that doing so is not in the public interest. A separate arrest by itself does not meet that second rule.

Can I seal some convictions but not others?

Yes. If some of your convictions are eligible and others aren't, you can petition to seal the eligible ones. The ineligible convictions remain on your record, but removing the eligible ones still reduces what shows up on a background check. Under the third-degree-felony limits, other felony convictions and the total conviction count can affect eligibility even if those other convictions cannot be sealed.

What if I'm not sure how many convictions Ohio counts me as having?

This is exactly why the counting tool matters. Order your BCI background check first (the guide explains how) so you can see every conviction on your record. Then work through the eligibility matrix with the third-degree-felony counting rules applied. Many people discover they have fewer countable convictions than they assumed — especially when multiple charges from one incident collapse into one.

How much does it cost to file multiple petitions?

The $50 application fee covers multiple cases in one application and can be waived with a poverty affidavit showing indigency; the court may also charge a local fee of up to $50. Filings in two counties generally require separate applications, so the state fees total $100 before any local fees. There is no statutory filing fee for non-conviction sealing under R.C. 2953.33. The guide plus two state application fees costs $24 + $100 before any local fees — compared to $1,000–$2,000 per case for an attorney.

Did SB 288 change the rules for people with multiple convictions?

Yes. SB 288 took effect April 4, 2023, and changed Ohio's sealing and expungement rules. People who were told before April 4, 2023, that they had too many convictions should re-check their eligibility under current law. The expansion was significant enough that the Ohio legislature specifically cited multi-conviction filers as one of the populations intended to benefit.

Get Your Free Ohio — Expungement Eligibility Checklist

Download the Ohio — Expungement Eligibility Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →