$0 Pennsylvania — Expungement Eligibility Checklist

How to Clear a Mixed-Case Docket in Pennsylvania Without a Lawyer

If you were arrested on multiple charges and some were dismissed while others resulted in convictions, you have a mixed-case docket — and clearing it requires two separate petitions filed under two different rules. This is the single most common source of confusion and wasted filing fees in Pennsylvania record clearing. Generic online advice treats every positive outcome as "expungement," but under Pennsylvania law, dismissed charges and convicted charges follow completely different legal paths with different forms, different eligibility rules, and different outcomes.

Here is how the process works, step by step, so you can decide whether to handle it yourself or hire an attorney.

What Makes a Docket "Mixed"

A mixed-case docket happens when a single arrest produces multiple charges and they end differently. The classic scenario: a felony charge is dismissed or withdrawn as part of a plea agreement, and you plead to a lesser misdemeanor. Your docket now has two categories of charges sitting side by side.

The problem is that standard background checks and public portal searches display the entire historical arrest event. A prospective employer or landlord sees the dismissed felony charge even though it never resulted in a conviction; licensing agencies may not use an arrest record with no conviction. Generic record-clearing websites call the whole thing "expungeable," which is legally wrong — a conviction may be expunged when a person reaches 70 and has been free of arrest or prosecution for ten years following final release from confinement or supervision, or after an unconditional gubernatorial pardon. What you can do is seek expungement of the dismissed portion and petition for limited access for the convicted portion, but these are separate legal actions.

The Two-Petition Process

Step Dismissed Charges Convicted Charges
Rule / procedure Rule 790 for court cases; Rule 790.2 for complete acquittals. Rule 490 and Rule 490.2 apply to separate summary cases. Rule 791 for petition-based limited access
Legal effect Covered record information is expunged; 18 Pa.C.S. § 9122(c) permits limited identifying information to be retained Limits public and noncriminal-justice access; criminal-justice agencies may retain access, but licensing agencies may not use covered convictions
Eligibility No conviction-based waiting period for dismissed or withdrawn charges; complete acquittals use a separate procedure 7 years free from conviction for a qualifying misdemeanor or 10 years for an eligible felony, plus payment of all court-ordered restitution and the authorized fee
DA response window 60 days under Rule 790 for court cases; 30 days under Rule 490 for summary cases 30 days under Rule 791
Restitution requirement Any restitution ordered on the case must be paid before Clean Slate limited access processing All court-ordered restitution and the authorized limited-access fee must be paid; unpaid fines or costs alone are not listed eligibility conditions
Filing fee $132 statutory fee plus county-authorized fees; eligible filers may request a waiver under Pa.R.J.A. 1990 $132 statutory fee plus county-authorized fees; Allegheny County lists $232 for an expungement petition

Why This Matters for Your Background Check

When the court orders expungement for the dismissed charges, it removes covered record information, though 18 Pa.C.S. § 9122(c) allows limited identifying information to be retained. Except where an exception applies, you may respond as if the offense did not occur when asked to disclose an expunged record. Convicted charges remain visible in ordinary records unless you separately obtain limited access through Rule 791.

If you file only the expungement petition and skip the sealing petition, your background check still shows the conviction. If you file only the sealing petition, the dismissed charges (including the felony that was dropped) remain visible to anyone searching the public court portal. You need both.

Free Download

Get the Pennsylvania — Expungement Eligibility Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Step-by-Step for Self-Filers

1. Order your PSP criminal history report. Submit Form SP 4-170 with a certified check or money order payable to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Rules 790 and 791 require a current report obtained within 60 days before filing unless the attorney for the Commonwealth waives it. Do this once — the same report covers both petitions if it is still current.

2. Map each charge to its category. Go through your docket line by line. In a court case, charges that ended in dismissal, withdrawal, or nolle prosequi go in the expungement column (Rule 790); a complete acquittal uses Rule 790.2. Rule 490 applies to a separate summary case, while Rule 490.2 covers a complete acquittal there. Every conviction that meets the waiting-period and restitution requirements goes in the limited-access column (Rule 791). Charges that do not qualify for either path stay where they are for now.

3. Prepare two separate petitions. Each petition must list only the charges it covers. The OTN (Offense Tracking Number), statutory citation, and disposition on each petition must match the official docket exactly — a mismatch is grounds for denial. The AOPC provides the templates.

4. File both petitions at the same courthouse. Both petitions go to the judicial district where the charges were disposed. Some counties accept both filings at the same window visit. Others require separate filing fees for each. Check your county's procedures and fee schedule before you go.

5. Serve the DA for each petition. The DA gets separate response windows for each. Rule 790 court-case expungement has a 60-day response window; Rule 490 summary-case expungement and Rule 791 limited access have 30-day windows. A complete-acquittal expungement uses Rule 490.2 or 790.2, with a 60-day period for the Commonwealth to object.

6. Wait for the court's orders. A judge may grant both petitions on the papers (common when the DA consents). If the DA objects to either, the judge decides whether to schedule a hearing. An objection to the sealing petition is more common than an objection to expunging dismissed charges.

7. Verify that both orders were executed. After the court grants both petitions, confirm that the PSP database reflects both changes and file FCRA disputes with any commercial background-check company still showing either the dismissed or the convicted charges.

Who This Is For

  • People whose arrest resulted in a plea to a lesser charge while other charges were dismissed or withdrawn
  • Self-filers comfortable managing two parallel petition processes for the same arrest
  • Anyone whose background check still shows dismissed felony charges alongside a misdemeanor conviction
  • People who have completed the waiting period and restitution requirements for the conviction portion

Who This Is NOT For

  • Anyone whose conviction portion involves immigration consequences — file nothing without consulting an immigration attorney first
  • People whose conviction does not yet meet the statutory waiting period for limited access
  • Cases where the DA is likely to contest the sealing petition and you are not prepared to represent yourself at a hearing
  • Individuals with the same mixed-case pattern across multiple counties (the two-petition process multiplies per county)

Common Mistakes That Waste Filing Fees

Using one petition for both types of relief. Rule 790 expungement and Rule 791 limited access use separate AOPC petition forms. File under the rule that matches the relief you are requesting.

Using an online background check instead of the PSP report. Commercial background checks are not official records. Rules 790 and 791 require a current Pennsylvania State Police criminal history report obtained through Form SP 4-170 unless the attorney for the Commonwealth waives it. Filing without it can result in the judge declining to rule until the report is filed.

Mismatching the OTN or statutory citation. The Offense Tracking Number and the statute cited on your petition must match the official docket exactly. A transposition error means the petition references a charge that does not exist on your record as filed, and the court will reject it.

Assuming Clean Slate already handled the dismissed charges. Clean Slate automatic limited access covers non-conviction records, but "sealing" and "expungement" produce different legal outcomes. Criminal-justice agencies may retain access to limited-access records; Pennsylvania licensing agencies may not use covered records. Expungement removes covered information, subject to the limited retention allowed by 18 Pa.C.S. § 9122(c). If you want court-case charges expunged after Clean Slate has limited access to them, file under Rule 790; Rule 490 applies to summary cases.

The Pennsylvania Expungement & Record Sealing Guide covers the entire mixed-case process in detail, including the eligibility decision tree for classifying each charge, county-specific filing procedures, and the five printable worksheets that keep both petition tracks organized from PSP request through post-order verification.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I file both petitions on the same day?

In most counties, yes. Both petitions are filed in the same judicial district because they come from the same docket. Some counties accept both at the same filing window; others require you to file them as separate transactions. Call the clerk of courts to confirm before your visit.

What if the DA consents to the expungement but objects to the sealing?

This is a common outcome. The court can grant the Rule 790 expungement for dismissed court-case charges independently of the Rule 791 petition for the conviction. If the DA objects to limited access, the judge decides whether to grant or deny the petition or schedule a hearing. The guide identifies this as a situation where hiring an attorney for the contested hearing is worth considering.

How long does the whole two-petition process take?

The expungement petition for dismissed court-case charges (Rule 790) can be filed without a conviction-based waiting period. The limited-access petition for the conviction depends on whether you have met the statutory waiting period — 7 years free from conviction for a qualifying misdemeanor or 10 years for an eligible felony, plus restitution and the authorized fee. Once both petitions are granted, PSP and commercial database updates add additional time.

Does clearing the dismissed charges help even if I cannot seal the conviction yet?

Yes. Removing the dismissed felony charge from your visible record means a background check shows only the misdemeanor conviction, not the original felony arrest. For employment and housing applications, this can make a significant practical difference even before the conviction portion becomes eligible for sealing.

Get Your Free Pennsylvania — Expungement Eligibility Checklist

Download the Pennsylvania — Expungement Eligibility Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →