How to Fix a Background Check After Your Washington Conviction Was Vacated
If you vacated a conviction in Washington and a commercial background check still reports it, the problem is not with the court — it is with the screening company's database. Vacating a conviction in Washington withdraws a guilty plea or sets aside a guilty verdict after a not-guilty plea, and dismisses the charging document. You can legally state for all purposes that you have never been convicted of that crime. A consumer reporting agency that obtained the record before the vacatur may still have outdated information. If it reports the conviction as active, you can dispute the inaccuracy through the FCRA process.
This is one of the most frustrating situations in the record-clearing process: you did everything right, the court granted the motion, the conviction is legally gone — and then a screening company reports it as though nothing changed. It happens because the commercial background check industry runs on stale data, and the burden of correcting that data falls on you.
Why Background Checks Still Show Vacated Convictions
Commercial screening companies build their databases by scraping public court records — the county docket, the state Judicial Information System, sometimes even physical courthouse records. If their data was collected before the court vacated a conviction, the stored record may not reflect the court's update. The FCRA requires consumer reporting agencies to use reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy. For employment reports that include adverse public-record information, an agency must either notify you when it reports the information, including the report user's name and address, or maintain strict procedures to ensure the information is complete and up to date when reported.
When a Washington court vacates a conviction, the court docket updates to reflect the new status. For misdemeanor and gross-misdemeanor vacaturs, the clerk must immediately transmit the order to WSP, and WSP must immediately update its record. For felony vacaturs, WSP may not disclose the vacated conviction. But the commercial screening company that pulled the docket six months ago may still have the old version. When an employer or landlord orders a background check, the company may report what is in its database — the pre-vacatur conviction — not the current court record.
Under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and Washington's Fair Credit Reporting Act (RCW 19.182), you have the right to dispute inaccurate information and force the screening company to reinvestigate.
The Dispute Process, Step by Step
Step 1: Identify the Screening Company
The employer, landlord, or licensing board that ran the check is required to tell you the name of the screening company. Under the FCRA, any entity that takes adverse action based on a consumer report must provide you with the name, address, and phone number of the consumer reporting agency that supplied the report. Request a copy of the report they used.
Step 2: Get Your Documentation Ready
Before you send the dispute letter, gather:
- A certified copy of the vacate order from the court
- Your current WSP WATCH report showing the updated record (order online or by mail from WSP)
- The screening report that shows the inaccurate conviction
The vacate order is the critical document. It proves the conviction no longer exists as a matter of law.
Step 3: Send the Dispute Letter
Send a written dispute to the screening company. The letter should:
- Identify the specific record being disputed (case number, court, date)
- State that the conviction was vacated by court order
- Attach a copy of the vacate order
- Request that the screening company update its records and provide you with a corrected report
- Reference the FCRA (15 U.S.C. § 1681i) and Washington RCW 19.182
Send the letter by certified mail with return receipt, or by another method that provides proof of delivery and date. The screening company's reinvestigation deadline runs from the date it receives your dispute.
Step 4: Track the 30-Day Reinvestigation Deadline
Once the screening company receives your dispute, it generally has 30 days to reinvestigate and correct the information if it is inaccurate. If you provide relevant additional information during the reinvestigation, the company may extend the period by up to 15 days. If the company deletes inaccurate information or adds a dispute notation, then at your request it must notify each person you specifically designate who received a report containing that information within the past two years for employment purposes or six months for any other purpose.
Step 5: Verify the Correction
After the reinvestigation period, request a new copy of your consumer file from the screening company. Confirm that the vacated conviction has been removed or updated. If it has not, you may have grounds for an FCRA enforcement action — the company's failure to correct verified inaccurate information after a dispute is a violation.
The Multi-Database Problem
Fixing one screening company does not fix them all. There are hundreds of consumer reporting agencies in the United States, and an employer, landlord, or licensing board may use a different one next time. Each company maintains its own database, and each one scraped the original conviction independently.
You have two practical strategies:
- Dispute reactively — wait until a specific screening company reports the vacated conviction, then dispute it with that company. This is free and addresses the immediate problem.
- Request your file proactively — under the FCRA, you can request a free file disclosure once every 12 months from each nationwide consumer reporting agency and nationwide specialty consumer reporting agency. If you are unemployed and intend to apply for work within the next 60 days, you can also request one free disclosure per year from any consumer reporting agency. The major employment screening companies (Sterling, First Advantage, GoodHire, Checkr, HireRight) each have a process for requesting your file. Pull it, and if the vacated conviction appears, dispute it before it causes a problem.
The Washington Expungement & Record Sealing Guide includes a Background Check Dispute Letter template and a Dispute Log for tracking multiple disputes across multiple screening companies — because the realistic scenario is not one dispute but several.
Free Download
Get the Washington — Expungement Eligibility Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Who This Is For
- Anyone who has already vacated a Washington conviction and is finding that background checks still report it
- People who lost a job offer, apartment, or licensing opportunity because a screening company reported a conviction that was legally vacated
- Job seekers who want to proactively check and correct commercial screening databases before their next application
- Anyone dealing with multiple screening companies reporting the same vacated conviction
Who This Is NOT For
- People whose convictions have not yet been vacated — the dispute process is for inaccurate reporting, not for convictions that are still legally active
- Anyone who wants to dispute an accurate conviction — the FCRA dispute process applies to inaccurate, incomplete, or unverifiable information
- People whose record appears only on the official WSP WATCH report or court docket and not on a commercial screening report — the correction process for official state records is different from the FCRA process
The Gap Between Legal Reality and Database Reality
Washington's vacatur statute is clear: once a conviction is vacated, the person may state for all purposes that they have never been convicted of that crime. The legal slate is clean. But the commercial screening industry does not operate on legal reality — it operates on cached data. A conviction that was vacated three years ago can still appear on a screening report today because the screening company may not have incorporated the vacatur into its records.
This gap is why the record-clearing process does not end at the court order. The court grants the vacatur. The WSP updates its database. But the third layer — the commercial screening companies that employers, landlords, and licensing boards actually use — requires its own separate correction process under the FCRA.
The Washington Expungement & Record Sealing Guide covers all three layers: the court process, the WSP verification, and the commercial background check dispute process. The Three-Track Filing System was designed around this reality — that clearing a Washington record means clearing three separate systems, not one.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a screening company have to fix an inaccurate background check?
Under the FCRA, the screening company generally has 30 days from receiving your dispute to reinvestigate and correct inaccurate information. If you provide relevant additional information during the reinvestigation, the company may extend the period by up to 15 days.
Do I need to dispute with every screening company separately?
Yes. Each consumer reporting agency maintains its own database. A correction at one company does not propagate to others. If you are applying to multiple employers or landlords that use different screening companies, you may need to dispute with each one individually.
Can I sue a screening company that keeps reporting a vacated conviction?
If a screening company fails to correct inaccurate information after you have properly disputed it under the FCRA, you may have grounds for a legal claim. The FCRA provides for actual damages, statutory damages of $100 to $1,000 for willful violations, and attorney's fees. Consult with a consumer rights attorney if the company fails to correct the information after your dispute.
Will the court automatically notify screening companies when it vacates a conviction?
No. Washington courts update their own docket and report the change to WSP, but they do not notify commercial screening companies. The burden is on you to dispute inaccurate reports with each screening company individually.
What if the WSP WATCH report still shows the conviction after it was vacated?
If the court granted the vacatur but the WSP record has not been updated, contact the court clerk's office to confirm the vacate order was entered and transmitted to WSP. If the court confirms it was transmitted, contact the WSP Criminal History Records Section directly. The guide includes the specific WSP verification steps and contact information for this situation.
Is there a time limit for disputing an inaccurate background check?
There is no FCRA deadline for initiating a dispute. You can dispute inaccurate information with a screening company at any time. However, acting quickly matters when a job offer, apartment, or license is on the line — especially during the Fair Chance Act's minimum two-business-day employer response window.
Get Your Free Washington — Expungement Eligibility Checklist
Download the Washington — Expungement Eligibility Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.